Broiled Sandwiches – A Sandwich for Everyone on Your Team

Football is the perfect excuse to make these individual broiled sandwiches. Does anyone else live with a football crazed, Patriots/Tom Brady super-fan who loves Super Bowl snacks, but is also trying to be health conscious? I can’t be the only one…ok maybe the part about being a Patriots super fan isn’t universal, but the rest might just ring true. My husband might be football crazed, but it turns out, I am crazed for these individual broiled sandwiches.
As Tom Brady and the gang draw closer to the end of the season and to the big game, I found myself wondering what Granny would have served a crew of hungry football fans. She loved entertaining and planning a menu, but would be Super Bowl really have been her cup of tea (or pint of beer, to be more thematically appropriate)?
Imagine my surprise when I found these little sandwiches while shuffling through the appetizer category of her recipe box. While the recipe card is uncharacteristically vague and unspecified, I loved the sound of little broiled sandwiches. Her recipe called only for cheese, peppers, onions and bacon. But with a larger crowd coming for the big game, my brother being a long-term houseguest and my sticking-to-his-healthy-resolution husband, I thought it would be fun to make a whole line-up of these little guys.
Individual Boiled Sandwiches
Before the Oven
Of course Granny’s original individual broiled sandwiches recipe was a must, but I wondered what are some other combos that would work? I settled on a roster that included a veggie version with my vegetarian, pregnant sister-in-law in mind. A sweet potato version for the toddlers in my life, and a meat lover’s version for those with more of a lineman appetite (i.e. my extended houseguest brother).
Individual Broiled Sandwiches
Different Variations for these Individual Broiled Sandwiches
Within these categories I made a few variations which I will break down further below in the Recipe Card.
With each individual broiled sandwich there was some prep I had to do before broiling. I sautéed the peppers and onions together. I also sautéed the mushrooms separately. I boiled and mashed the sweet potato, and I cooked the bacon. I also lightly fried the egg enough to hold its shape so it wouldn’t run all over the sheet pan. Once I had all of the sandwiches assembled, I broiled on high for about 4 minutes. I did have to take the sandwich with marshmallows out after about 2 minutes, but the rest were closer to 4.
Finished Individual Broiled Sandwiches
Nice and Broiled
Although the variation of these individual broiled sandwiches with marshmallows wasn’t pretty enough for a picture, it was very tasty. Altogether, I made 12 sandwiches that were devoured quickly between my 3 football loving sandwich testers. While all of the sandwiches were playoff worthy, the true MVPs of the group were the sandwich topped with a fried egg and the meat lover’s versions.
Individual Broiled Sandwiches
Veggie Broiled Sandwich with a perfectly fried egg

I’ll definitely be making these combos for our company during the big game. Since making these sandwiches  last weekend, I’ve thought of several other versions I want to try out: Mexican, ham, egg & cheese, and cheeseburger to name a few.

I hope your team is still alive in this playoff season, and if so, make these individual broiled sandwiches for the game this weekend. And if not, make them anyway and eat your feelings. They might just make you feel better. And let me know what combinations you come up with!


Broiled Sandwiches
Cook Time
5 mins
Total Time
15 mins

These little Broiled Sandwiches are perfect for an appetizer, a lunch with friends or a hearty snack while watching the big game. With a variation for everyone, these are sure to be a crowd pleaser!

Course: Appetizer, Lunch, Snack
Cuisine: American, Kid Friendly, Sandwich, Vegan, Vegetarian
Author: Maddy L.
  • Rolls I used brioche rolls and french bread as the base for these sandwiches
Vegetarian Version
  • Peppers
  • Oinions
  • Mushrooms
  • Spinach
  • Cheese
  • Fried Egg (optional)
Sweet Potato (Any Combination of the Following)
  • Sweet Potato
  • Banana
  • Cinnamon Sugar
  • Honey
  • Marshmallows
  • Raisins
Meat Lover's
  • Roast Beef
  • Bacon
  • Sausage
  • Cheese
  • Peppers
  • Onions
  • Mushrooms
  • Mustard
  1. Prepare any toppings that need to be pre-cooked. I.e.sauté the peppers and onions together, sautéed the mushrooms, boiled and mash the sweet potato or cooked the bacon. Lightly the egg enough to hold its shape so it wouldn’t run in the sheet pan.

  2. On a sheet pan, arrange sandwiches and toppings (I left off the mustard and honey drizzles until after the sandwiches were broiled)

  3. Broil on high for 4 minutes (check after 2 minutes for certain toppings such as marshmallows)

  4. Add drizzle after the sandwiches are broiled (mustard or honey)

Broiled Sandwich Long Pin
Broiled Sandwich Combo Pin
Broiled Sandwiches - Meat